Year: 2020

Radiant Dreams

The architect sent something back to the permit expeditor, so maybe that’s moving forward? I’m not sure. Something else to follow up on. We don’t have a new roof yet, but we still have a round 8″ hole in the roof that lets in the rain. Apparently the “Estate Gray” color is out of stock everywhere for the rest of the year. Instead we’re getting Onyx Black, which I don’t like as much, but hopefully at at least they can install it. I suspected when we had beautiful weather at the beginning of the month that it meant we weren’t getting our roof, and so it was. The weather has turned to cold and rainy, and even though we settled on the “in stock” color a week ago, no word yet as to when they’ll be putting it on.

I pinged the concrete guy since two weeks had turned to three. He said the end of this week as long as it didn’t rain. Well the end of the week is here, and it’s been rainy. Next week temperatures are dropping into the thirties; not great for pouring concrete. I haven’t heard back from him yet about a new date.

I asked the radiant company if there was any way to lower the cost (partially since they had originally quoted me much lower, suggesting such a thing was possible) and they never responded. I considered just putting down a half inch of plywood and heating with minisplits, but this is a feature of the house we’re really set on and don’t want to give up. If I had it to do over, I might have skipped it, but we’re committed at this point.

Instead, I started measuring, whiteboarding, planning, spreadsheeting, and SketchUping (I promise at least some of these are real verbs). The result is a complete hydronic radiant floor panel plan of equally-balanced loops each under the maximum length that all connect back to a central manifold.

First Floor Radiant Plan

There are apparently tools to help you do this, but I didn’t have them, so I made some formulas in Google Sheets, I fired up SketchUp, and I worked it out. It’s not the most elegant design, but it keeps the loops all the same size, which is the real trick. Since each floor is one temperature zone, it doesn’t especially matter if the loops are divided into discrete areas of the floor, just that they are the same size so that the manifold will flow evenly throughout.

After I worked out the first floor, the second floor came together more quickly, even though it’s quite a bit more complicated, since there are more rooms and less open space. The first step was to cover the house in rectangles that had a dimension divisible by 7″, the width of one panel. Cutting them down is certainly possible, but it will go much faster if I only do length cuts with the chop saw. The total square footage (actually I worked in square inchage) is divided to an ideal size for each loop. Then I come up with a layout plan that works. I had to work out ways to “borrow” from one loop to make another the right size, and then work back through the remaining adjacent loops to even everything out. If I came across something that changed the area to cover, everything had to be recalibrated. It was a bit of a pain.

Second Floor Radiant

After a few days I had all the loops designed. The next step was to measure up the total length of the straight and return sections to come up with exactly how much I needed to buy. I used another spreadsheet formula to confirm my panel coverage matched my area and saved myself a ton of errors. After finding the best deal online, paying the equivalent of a decent used compact car, and clicking the order button, I had a glass of scotch and wondered —not for the first time— about my life choices.

So many boxes!

Just a couple of days later, I got a delivery notification and went out front to find the above box collection in the front yard. I’m not sure why they didn’t ring the doorbell, but as each box weighs about 60 lbs and it was a short enough time, none of it walked off (to my knowledge). We got it all inside and I’m now in the process of carting it up to the attic, one of the few places we’re not putting in-floor radiant heat and it hopefully won’t be in the way.

I emailed the radiant contractor (again) this time asking for a revised quote where they just install the pumps and controls. I have a miter saw, a collated screw gun, and the ability to follow directions, so I plan to take some time off work and put this stuff in myself. In theory, we’ll save a chunk of money in the process. If I’m lucky, it may all wind up costing around what they wanted to charge in the first place. We’ll see if they respond this time.

My preference is not to install the floor panels until the drywall is in to ensure it doesn’t get damaged, so that will be a while, especially at the pace things are going. I’ll still need the manifolds installed and the pex run through the walls, but I think I can manage that in a weekend or two. Wish me luck!

Contractor Struggles

This is starting to feel like a theme. I mentioned last time that I had to put down a bunch of money for HVAC (specifically the hydronic radiant heat) and they were coming out to do the layout. Well, the good news is that I got a refund of all that money, but the bad news is that’s because they ‘underbid’ and can’t do it for what they said because material costs are so high. Apparently there was a misunderstanding of what they needed to do. They gave me a new quote for about 50% more, so now I’m trying to figure out what to do.

Meanwhile, we got kicked back from Zoning a second time and I’m probably going to have to nag the architect to do his job again. I haven’t called him yet; I keep clinging to the hope that he’ll actually respond to email.

There’s more back and forth with paperwork for the initial draw for the loan. I needed to print, sign, scan, and email back more documents. I haven’t heard from the concrete guy that was supposed to be out this week to do the porch footings. I haven’t heard back from the other HVAC guy about the air conditioning. I had questions for him about the outdoor condensers and wall penetrations.

All in all, the only work that’s been done is what I did. I started putting up sound insulating stud and joist tape in interior walls and ceiling of the bedrooms. This wasn’t cheap, but the benefits of better sound proofing are obvious, from our current reality of looping Frozen 2 and Super Smash Bros Ultimate songs or us wanting to watch a movie after the kids go to bed to a future where one or both play musical instruments, this will pay quality of life dividends.

Derek’s bedroom with sound insulating joist and stud tape

The tape is one of three components to our interior sound proofing strategy, along with two layers of 5/8″ drywall on the ceilings (separated by sound glue) and Roxul mineral wool insulation in the interior stud bays.

I still have a long way to go on this project, but Derek’s bedroom is done, Emily’s is next, and from there I’ll do our bedroom, the bathrooms, and the attic bedrooms. We’re not putting this on exterior walls. I figure between the closed cell foam in the stud bays and the 2″ of rigid foam on the outside of the sheathing, we should be in pretty good shape already.

Odds and Ends

I’ve been trying to work through my list. As is typical, progress is stymied by unexpected complications and I add new items nearly as quickly as I cross off old ones. The priority is the roof and wall penetrations, so they can do the roof and siding before the weather changes. I have most of those done now, with Dean’s help to cut holes for the bath exhaust fans and the kitchen range hood. I had cut a hole for that a couple years back, but I changed my mind about where to put it. Still to do are the exterior electrical boxes, which requires the electrician, and prepping the area where the air conditioner condenser mounting goes, which should require the HVAC tech, but he’s busy, so I may wind up doing that.

The architect got the last form in for permit, so hopefully that process will now proceed smoothly. I have the concrete contractor lined up to put in the porch footings but I’m not certain when. We had an inspection from the bank appraiser to view the lack of work to date in order to release some initial funds to the contractors. We wound up having to float some of the money for the down payment because the bank will only front for certain categories and HVAC isn’t one of them.

Powder room ceiling with exhaust fan bracket

The powder room on the first floor needed a lowered ceiling to allow for some pipes above, so I got that built. I cut the hole and framed in where the solar tube is going to go through the second floor. I put in all the missing nailing edges for drywall, got the washer drain box ready to go, but I still have some gluing to do for the plumbing. I got the metal plates in that protect the plumbing in as well as the straps to secure pipes in the walls. The radiant contractor is coming out today to lay out where everything is going to go.

Solar Tube Chase

All in all, there’s been some decent progress, but not much that’s noticeable and visible. I got word that they’re struggling to find the shingles we picked out. If they can’t find them we’ll need to either switch to a different shingle or a different color. Antique Silver doesn’t look as nice as Estate Gray, so I’m hoping they can track it down.

Finally, the Loan

After several months, Thursday we closed on our construction loan! This was a long, drawn-out process, and I haven’t been making updates because it’s been frustrating paperwork and contractor wrangling and not worth sharing. We’re working on new permits, but we’re expecting that will be done in as little as a few weeks. Things are about to get pretty crazy, so I figured I should get back on the update wagon and keep everyone appraised. If you’re interested, we went with US Bank for their loan program. It lets us start from an unfinished state, and it converts to a traditional mortgage at the end.

We have most of the drain plumbing done, save some odds and ends. I have a list of things that I need to get wrapped up that is collecting new items faster than I’m getting things checked off. The top priority is the remaining roof and wall penetrations, which need to be in before the new roof and the siding.

The roof will be Owens Corning Duration Flex shingles, which should last through hail and wind and all the rest so I don’t have to get back onto that stupid ladder and the death trap of a roof again (except for the aforementioned penetrations).

Siding Samples – stay tuned to see which color we picked

Unfortunately, all of the house wrap will need to come off since it’s been exposed for too long. The windows that I installed I used the clips they gave me, which are apparently the wrong clips, and as a result all of the windows are at the wrong depth. They’ll put on Blueskin instead, which is a better product anyway. On top of that will go the two inches of rigid polyisocyanurate insulation and furring strips. If I had it to do over, I’d probably have stepped down to one inch, because we’d have a lot more siding options. As it is, with two inches of foam we basically have to use Hardie Plank cement fiber siding if we want it to be covered by warranty.

I wish the house wrap and the windows were the only thing that needs to be re-done, but they’re also going to redo some of the front porch structure as well because the wood we bought twisted and warped after we installed it. Our builder doesn’t recommend buying lumber from Menards, and now I can see why.

With the pandemic dragging on, we’re still working from home and the kids are at home for school. We’re not sure how this will work with construction taking place and we’re considering our options for vacating by the hour, day, week, and month. So, there’s a lot of exciting work about to start, and I need to go add a couple more things to my to do list!

What’s Going On?

All this time and no updates. Obviously I haven’t made the blog a priority, and to an extent, the house hasn’t been either. At one point I did write a whole, thorough update, but then I ran into WordPress issues and it didn’t save and I didn’t feel like starting over. That was… months ago. I’m sorry; the house has been been depressing and overwhelming, and writing about the low spots instead of the high spots makes it seem all the worse.

The short version is that we’re still living in the basement, and not much has changed. Why is that, when we were getting quotes and getting ready to get it all done last year? Well, because we finally got quotes. Really big, really expensive quotes. We started going through and trimming things, because we’d asked for what we wanted knowing that we probably couldn’t get it all, but figuring we might as well start there.

We kept trimming, and kept trimming, and in spite of that, the project remained stubbornly expensive to finish. We discussed what we could delay and do later, what we could do ourselves, what we could live without. Honestly, spending so much time on this project, chipping away at it, we’d clung to the dream of what the finished project would be like, so this was fairly painful, giving up things we really wanted. We tried getting alternate quotes, spent more weeks trying to get better numbers, and while we made progress, we ultimately got stuck on a few key points.

First, the total cost, not just the quote of work to be done, but the overall math: what we originally paid for the house, what we’ve put into it so far (just in materials and paid labor, not counting our time), the quote itself, and finally an estimate of what we’d still have to pay down the road. When we add those numbers together, it should be less than the cost of buying an already finished house, otherwise there’s not much point in all this “sweat equity” and basement living we’ve been doing for years and years.

Second, the monthly cost: every ten grand of loan is $50 a month of mortgage payment, even with low rates. Every $50 a month we spend on the house is $50 we don’t have for anything else: savings, furnishings, going out to dinner, going on trips. The work we’re putting off for later still needs to be paid for, and if it’s not in the loan, it’s out of pocket.

Third, I’m obviously cheap. No one that wasn’t cheap would take on a project like this, and a lot of the numbers were just plain high. I’ve come to accept that we don’t really have the free time needed to do finish this project ourselves. But I still have an idea of what labor is involved, what materials cost, and the resultant profit I’m potentially paying someone. I don’t begrudge someone a living, but some of the numbers were just beyond the pale.

All of that meant we didn’t move forward on the plan, even though we didn’t have a better path forward. We didn’t magically have more time and we didn’t have the cash on hand to pay to get parts of the work done. We discussed trying to get all the mechanicals done ourselves or out of pocket so we could spray foam ourselves, and with Dean’s help I’ve done a fair bit of work on the drain and vent plumbing. Besides saving money, it ensures it’s done the way I want it, without soffits everywhere. I’ll make a post about that when it’s closer to done.

With the Covid-19 pandemic and everyone at home, it would sure be nice to have the whole house done, instead of us all crammed into the basement. Unfortunately, we don’t have much more free time than usual because we both have work-from-home day jobs, the kids need help with home schooling, and the house gets messier with everyone home all the time. When we do have free time, it’s kind of nice to spend it with the kids or relaxing rather than fighting the house.

The swing set

I did take the time to build a swing set in the back yard from some leftover pressure treated lumber for the kids. We set up some toys for them to play with in the empty first floor and put up a basketball hoop in the back, since we can’t go anywhere.

We’re back to trying with the same contractor, getting new quotes and trying to hammer this into something we can stomach. We still want the house done, we need siding. At this point all that cursed house wrap will need to be replaced. It’s torn loose in more places and flaps noisily in the wind, an ongoing reminder of the unfinished project. I’d like to get a quote from a different GC, it would either reinforce that the prices are fair or give us another option. I’ve got some recommendations I need to call. One way or another, we’re getting it done. We have a goal of finishing it by Christmas, but to be honest that was the goal last year too.